Black tea headache

I had some keemun yesterday in a mug. Nothing harmful, I thought, but at the end of that, I could start to feel a little of that same headache creeping in. It was not yet a major concern, nor the rather annoying headache that I’ve had recently after drinking blacks, but nonetheless… it’s there.

It’s a strange thing. I’ve never had a problem like this before, where drinking one type of tea leads to a headache. I deliberately used less leaves than usual and maybe that’s what allowed me to avoid a full on headache, but the mere presence of it is disturbing, to say the least.

Then I drank some of my aged baozhong, which always serve me well in a pinch….and no problems.

What could black tea have that causes this? Pesticide?


Comments

Black tea headache — 17 Comments

  1. I don’t know if it’s pesticides, but I get headaches from Darjeeling and Bai Hao (and sometimes similarly-oxidized teas). It seems to be so consistent with teas around that oxidation level that I am led to believe it is somehow a factor.

    Brent

    • A lot of black tea has caffeine in it which can definitely cause headaches. I’ve been having the same issue, I drink a LOT of tea (black teas in particular) and I have to balance it out with water breaks in between to avoid headaches.

  2. MarshalN,

    It’s hard to isolate this kind of reaction… It could be pesticide as you mention, even fertilizer that grew into the leaves. However, I doubt that those are the causes.

    From my own experience, I used to get headaches from any black tea. I wasn’t sure why, but it seemed to be from the abundance of tannins, caffeine and bitterness. It had been years since I tried black tea again, but with my new knowledge of gong fu cha, I can again drink black tea. When I brew black tea with short steepings, I get a light, full cup of black tea for 3-4 infusions and NO HEADACHE! I think consuming tea nutrients with right water ratio is important, like brewing other teas, black tea is no exception. I realize traditionally in the west, black tea (or red tea) is steeped 3-5 mins. That simply does not work for me. Try gong fu keemum, and let us know if it improves your experience.

    Michael

  3. Black tea shouldn’t be bitter if brewed correctly. And doesn’t the Puerh have a certain amount of caffeine? Lack of caffeine for someone who is used to a certain amount generally will cause headache and haven’t you recently adjusted your tea-drinking schedule to begin earlier? Or was that just a pipe dream? Maybe you should try an organic black to eliminate the pesticide theory although I worry about where teas are stored when warehoused as well. I think organics have to be stored more stringently and that might be a start. Have you tried any other black tea lately besides the keemun? Hoping you solve this mystery soon, Eileen

  4. Interesting post. I also get headaches, or more often, a sore neck from drinking many black assam or darjeelings. Strange thing is adding milk to these teas prevent the headaches or sore necks. Go figure.

  5. Maybe it’s the sugar in the milk? Definitely needs research or maybe you should turn back to greens. You never explained why you cannot drink green tea anymore. I find it soothing, with a caffeine lift. And white teas, much more of a caffeine lift. Have you tried Toki’s 21-days steeping? Maybe that would alleviate the headache. So much tea, so little time. Eileen

  6. Came upon this while trying to figure out why I have an ocular migraine. It’s the only thing I can think caused it, but can’t find much about it, just that it happens! Scared to drink it now because I don’t know if I’ll have this reaction. Bummer.

  7. I’ve been drinking tea for years (hot and iced). I started getting migraines many years ago and it took until recently to realise they are coming from all Camellia sinensis products. Teas and many cosmetics contain the plant. 🙁 I know it’s not caffeine because I drink many cups of coffee in the a.m. The lotions for the face were also triggering my “hay fever” . Terrible thing is that I was using green tea to relieve migraine symptoms and I could not understand why things were only getting worse.

    • Same for me. A lot of migraines which I could not understand for long time why they are keep happening. The answer is same as yours: tea. And it’s definetely not caffeine because coffee has no such effect at all.

  8. I have read that black tea is fermented and people who are sensitive to tyramine will get a migraine. But I’m gonna try adding some milk to my tea although I prefer it black, but I don’t want anymore migraines either.

    • As Black tea is a fermented tea, it is a migrain trigger for some. But when I add a cardomom in the tea, then I don’t get the headache.

  9. A coworker got me into the Twinings tea a few weeks ago and I bough a variety pack. I’ve had headaches for days and have never had problems drinking black tea before. Thanks to Google, I found this chain. Thank you all for the insight!

  10. Black tea is high enough in fructans that Monash University has rated it as a high FODMAP. If you have trouble digesting FODMAPS like Fructans then you could be getting a headache as a symptom.

Leave a Reply to MarshalN Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.